1909 E95 Baseball

What is the 1909 E95 Philadelphia Caramel baseball card set? The 1909 E95 set is the first baseball card issue of the Philadelphia Caramel Company of Camden, New Jersey, a company founded in 1900 by German immigrant Jakob Schleicher and his stepson Adolph Ebeling. The set has just 25 cards, small color lithographs with white borders, each showing the player's last name, team city and league at the bottom, with a numbered checklist of all 25 players printed on the back, one of the first sets to carry that feature.

For a 25-card set, E95 packs an extraordinary amount of star power: ten of the 25 players are Hall of Famers, including Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Christy Mathewson, Eddie Plank, Chief Bender, Frank Chance, Eddie Collins, Sam Crawford, Johnny Evers and Vic Willis. Players from only six of the 16 major league teams of the time are represented, and the player selection has puzzled collectors ever since. The artwork is unique to E95 and was not reused by other manufacturers, which is unusual among the caramel issues of the era, when the same poses were often shared across sets. Philadelphia Caramel followed E95 with the E96 set in 1910, a 30-card issue with an entirely different checklist. How the E95 cards were distributed or packaged has never been pinned down.

The cards in this collection are led by a Vic Willis card graded SGC 1.5, a Solly Hoffman card graded SGC 3, a Johnny Evers card graded PSA A and a Nick Maddox card graded SGC 2.5. An Ed Willett card graded SGC 1 is also in the collection. Short, sweet and star-studded, the E95 set is one of the most completable and most rewarding pre-war sets in the hobby.

Frequently asked questions

How many cards are in the 1909 E95 set? The set has just 25 cards, ten of which picture future Hall of Famers.

What is the E96 set? The 1910 follow-up from Philadelphia Caramel, with 30 cards and a completely different checklist from E95.

Who are the key cards in E95? Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Christy Mathewson and Eddie Plank lead a checklist that is 40 percent Hall of Famers.

Sort by:
1909 E95 LARRY DOYLE NNO POOR PHILADELPHIA CARAMEL SGC 1 NEW YORK GIANTS

1909 E95 LARRY DOYLE NNO POOR PHILADELPHIA CARAMEL SGC 1 NEW YORK GIANTS

$108.00
This LARRY DOYLE, from the 1909 E95 set, is in POOR condition. This NEW YORK GIANTS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$108.00
1909 E95 ED WILLETT NNO POOR PHILADELPHIA CARAMEL SGC A BASEBALL DETROIT TIGERS

1909 E95 ED WILLETT NNO POOR PHILADELPHIA CARAMEL SGC A BASEBALL DETROIT TIGERS

$108.00
This ED WILLETT, from the 1909 E95 set, is in POOR condition. This DETROIT TIGERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$108.00
1909 E95 CY MORGAN PHILADELPHIA CARAMEL SGC A GOOD PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS

1909 E95 CY MORGAN PHILADELPHIA CARAMEL SGC A GOOD PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS

$108.00
This CY MORGAN, from the 1909 E95 set, is in GOOD condition. This PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$108.00