1887 N172 Baseball & Boxing
What is the 1887 N172 Baseball & Boxing collection? The 1887 N172 Old Judge set is the first great baseball card set — and, in many ways, the first trading card set of any kind. Issued by Goodwin & Company of New York between 1887 and 1890 to promote Old Judge and Gypsy Queen cigarettes, it used real sepia albumen photographs pasted onto thick cardboard, and it is still the largest card issue ever made. This collection gathers the store's three in-stock 1887 N172 cards, including a Dell Darling batting card graded SGC 3 at $3,000, a California Brown card graded PSA Authentic at $720, and a Jack Dempsey boxing card graded SGC 2 at $720.
The cards measure about 1-1/2 by 2-1/2 inches, with a blank back and the Goodwin & Co. name at the base of the photograph. There is no true N172 set list — the cards were never numbered and no formal checklist was ever published — but more than 500 players have been documented across more than 40 major and minor league teams, plus boxers and wrestlers, and counting pose, team, and caption variations, more than 4,500 different cards are known. The stars include Cap Anson, Dan Brouthers, Roger Connor, Buck Ewing, Pud Galvin, Kid Nichols, and Old Hoss Radbourne, and the set's photographs, taken by the Hall Studio in New York, are the earliest comprehensive visual record of professional baseball.
Completing N172 is effectively impossible, which is why collectors chase it one card at a time. The Darling card leading this collection, graded SGC 3, is a strong mid-grade example of a Chicago White Stockings catcher in a batting pose. The Brown card pictures the Boston catcher in a throwing pose, and the Dempsey card is one of the set's boxing subjects, from the era's bare-knuckle champions. All three are in stock now.
Frequently asked questions
Who issued the N172 Old Judge cards? Goodwin & Company of New York, in packs of Old Judge and Gypsy Queen cigarettes, from 1887 to 1890.
How many different N172 cards exist? More than 500 players are documented, with over 4,500 variations counting poses, teams, and captions; no complete checklist was ever published.
Are there non-baseball cards in the set? Yes — the issue also includes boxers and wrestlers, like the Jack Dempsey boxing card in this collection.
