1887 Old Judge Baseball

What is the 1887 Old Judge Baseball? The Old Judge set, catalogued as N172, is the premier nineteenth-century baseball card issue and one of the largest sets ever produced. Issued by Goodwin and Company for its Old Judge and Gypsy Queen cigarette brands from 1887 to 1890, it features sepia-toned photographic portraits of ballplayers, each measuring about 1-1/2 by 2-1/2 inches. More than 500 players are known, with over 3,500 different cards once poses, team changes and caption variations are counted, No complete checklist has ever been confirmed.

The set is a portrait of baseball in its earliest professional years. Cap Anson, Dan Brouthers, Buck Ewing, Charles Comiskey and Connie Mack are among the early legends pictured, along with hundreds of major and minor leaguers from the National League, the American Association and the minor leagues. Many players appear in several different poses, in uniform or in street clothes, and the cards were distributed in cigarette packs, with advertising posters claiming over 2,000 different subjects. The N172 designation comes from Jefferson Burdick's American Card Catalog, where N marks a nineteenth-century issue.

This collection holds 33 in-stock Old Judge cards, led by a Sam Smith graded SGC 7 at $3,600, a John Ward graded SGC 2 at $2,640, and a Farmer Vaughn graded SGC 3 at $2,400. These are among the oldest cards in the store, and they are also among the scarcest: only a few thousand Old Judge cards have ever been graded, and fewer than 100 have graded 8 or higher. Assembling a complete N172 set is considered impossible, For a collector of baseball history, an Old Judge card is the closest thing to a photograph of the game as it was played in the 1880s.

Frequently asked questions

How many cards are in the Old Judge set? There is no confirmed total: more than 500 players are known, with over 3,500 card varieties once poses and variations are counted.

When were Old Judge cards issued? From 1887 to 1890 by Goodwin and Company, in Old Judge and Gypsy Queen cigarette packs.

Why are Old Judge cards so scarce in high grade? They are more than 135 years old, were handled by smokers and children, and very few were ever preserved; fewer than 100 have graded 8 or higher.

Sort by:
1887 OLD JUDGE SAM SMITH 424-2 NRMT N172 THROWING SGC 7 DES MOINES

1887 OLD JUDGE SAM SMITH 424-2 NRMT N172 THROWING SGC 7 DES MOINES

$3,600.00
This SAM SMITH, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in NRMT condition. This DES MOINES PROHIBITIONISTS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$3,600.00
1887 OLD JUDGE JOHN WARD NNO GOOD SLIDING N172 HOF RARE SGC 2 NEW YORK GIANTS

1887 OLD JUDGE JOHN WARD NNO GOOD SLIDING N172 HOF RARE SGC 2 NEW YORK GIANTS

$2,640.00
This JOHN WARD, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD condition. This NEW YORK GIANTS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$2,640.00
1887 OLD JUDGE FARMER VAUGHN NNO VG CATCHING RARE SGC 3 LOUISVILLE COLONELS

1887 OLD JUDGE FARMER VAUGHN NNO VG CATCHING RARE SGC 3 LOUISVILLE COLONELS

$2,400.00
This FARMER VAUGHN, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in vg condition. This LOUISVILLE COLONELS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$2,400.00
1887 OLD JUDGE BILL HOWES 237-3 EX+ N172 FIELDING SGC 5.5 MINNEAPOLIS MILLERS

1887 OLD JUDGE BILL HOWES 237-3 EX+ N172 FIELDING SGC 5.5 MINNEAPOLIS MILLERS

$2,040.00
This BILL HOWES, from the nan OLD JUDGE set, is in EX+ condition. This MINNEAPOLIS MILLERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$2,040.00
1887 OLD JUDGE ROBERT EMMERKE 145-4 PITCH R HAND HEAD HIGH SGC 5.5 DES MOINES

1887 OLD JUDGE ROBERT EMMERKE 145-4 PITCH R HAND HEAD HIGH SGC 5.5 DES MOINES

$2,040.00
This ROBERT EMMERKE, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in EXMT+ condition. This DES MOINES PROHIBITIONISTS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$2,040.00
1887 OLD JUDGE COUNT WEBER 482-5 PITCH RIGHT HAND CHIN HIGH SGC 5 SIOUX CITY

1887 OLD JUDGE COUNT WEBER 482-5 PITCH RIGHT HAND CHIN HIGH SGC 5 SIOUX CITY

$1,800.00
This COUNT WEBER, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in EXMT condition. This SIOUX CITY CORN HUSKERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple...
$1,800.00
1887 OLD JUDGE WILLIAM KLUSMAN 265-4 EXMT N172 CATCH HEAD HIGH SGC 5 DENVER

1887 OLD JUDGE WILLIAM KLUSMAN 265-4 EXMT N172 CATCH HEAD HIGH SGC 5 DENVER

$1,800.00
This WILLIAM KLUSMAN, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in EXMT condition. This DENVER GRIZZLIES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$1,800.00
1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE MCVEY 321-2 BENDING L HAND NEAR WAIST SGC 5 DENVER

1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE MCVEY 321-2 BENDING L HAND NEAR WAIST SGC 5 DENVER

$1,800.00
This GEORGE MCVEY, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in EXMT condition. This DENVER GRIZZLIES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$1,800.00
1887 OLD JUDGE BILL FAGAN NNO N172 GAI 5 EX BASEBALL KANSAS CITY COWBOYS

1887 OLD JUDGE BILL FAGAN NNO N172 GAI 5 EX BASEBALL KANSAS CITY COWBOYS

$1,800.00
This BILL FAGAN, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in EX condition. This KANSAS CITY COWBOYS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$1,800.00
1887 OLD JUDGE JOHN TENER 454-3 BALL IN R HAND THIGH HIGH SGC 1.5 WHITE STOCKING

1887 OLD JUDGE JOHN TENER 454-3 BALL IN R HAND THIGH HIGH SGC 1.5 WHITE STOCKING

$1,560.00
This JOHN TENER, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in FAIR condition. This CHICAGO WHITE STOCKINGS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$1,560.00
1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE TREADWAY 463-4 BALL AT CHEST N172 SGC 2 ST. PAUL APOSTLES

1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE TREADWAY 463-4 BALL AT CHEST N172 SGC 2 ST. PAUL APOSTLES

$1,440.00
This GEORGE TREADWAY, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD condition. This ST. PAUL APOSTLES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$1,440.00
1887 OLD JUDGE CURTIS WELCH 485-2 BAT AT READY LOOKING AT CAMERA SGC 1 ATHLETICS

1887 OLD JUDGE CURTIS WELCH 485-2 BAT AT READY LOOKING AT CAMERA SGC 1 ATHLETICS

$1,200.00
This CURTIS WELCH, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in POOR condition. This PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$1,200.00
1887 OLD JUDGE FRANK DWYER 141-3 BAT IN R HAND AT SIDE SGC 3 WHITE STOCKINGS

1887 OLD JUDGE FRANK DWYER 141-3 BAT IN R HAND AT SIDE SGC 3 WHITE STOCKINGS

$1,200.00
This FRANK DWYER, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in VG condition. This CHICAGO WHITE STOCKINGS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$1,200.00
1887 OLD JUDGE MICHAEL GOODFELLOW NNO GOOD+ N172 SGC 2.5 DETROIT WOLVERINES

1887 OLD JUDGE MICHAEL GOODFELLOW NNO GOOD+ N172 SGC 2.5 DETROIT WOLVERINES

$1,200.00
This MICHAEL GOODFELLOW, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD+ condition. This DETROIT WOLVERINES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$1,200.00
1887 OLD JUDGE BOBBY LOWE 281-1 GOOD LINK BAT AT SIDE N172 SGC 2 CREAM CITYS

1887 OLD JUDGE BOBBY LOWE 281-1 GOOD LINK BAT AT SIDE N172 SGC 2 CREAM CITYS

$1,020.00
This BOBBY LOWE, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD condition. This MILWAUKEE CREAM CITYS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$1,020.00
1887 OLD JUDGE ROBERT BURKS NNO N172 GAI 3 VG BASEBALL SIOUX CITY CORN HUSKERS

1887 OLD JUDGE ROBERT BURKS NNO N172 GAI 3 VG BASEBALL SIOUX CITY CORN HUSKERS

$840.00
This ROBERT BURKS, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in VG condition. This SIOUX CITY CORN HUSKERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple...
$840.00
1887 OLD JUDGE SY SUTCLIFFE 447-4 BAT AT READY LOOKING AT CAMERA SGC 2 SPIDERS

1887 OLD JUDGE SY SUTCLIFFE 447-4 BAT AT READY LOOKING AT CAMERA SGC 2 SPIDERS

$780.00
This SY SUTCLIFFE, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD condition. This CLEVELAND SPIDERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$780.00
1887 OLD JUDGE PARK SWARTZEL 450-1 GOOD N172 BAT ON R SHOULDER SGC A COWBOYS

1887 OLD JUDGE PARK SWARTZEL 450-1 GOOD N172 BAT ON R SHOULDER SGC A COWBOYS

$720.00
This PARK SWARTZEL, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD condition. This KANSAS CITY COWBOYS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$720.00
1887 OLD JUDGE NED WILLIAMSON 502-4 HANDS ABOVE HEAD SGC 1 WHITE STOCKINGS

1887 OLD JUDGE NED WILLIAMSON 502-4 HANDS ABOVE HEAD SGC 1 WHITE STOCKINGS

$720.00
This NED WILLIAMSON, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in POOR condition. This CHICAGO WHITE STOCKINGS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$720.00
1887 OLD JUDGE A.M. TUCKERMAN VG-EX WILLIAM N172 SGC A ST. PAUL APOSTLES

1887 OLD JUDGE A.M. TUCKERMAN VG-EX WILLIAM N172 SGC A ST. PAUL APOSTLES

$600.00
This A.M. TUCKERMAN, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in VG-EX condition. This ST. PAUL APOSTLES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$600.00
Load More
You've viewed 20 of 33 products