1890 J.L. Prescott & Co Baseball, Cricket, Croquet, Cycling, Football, Golf, Rowing & Tennis
What is the 1890 J.L. Prescott & Co. Enameline set? The 1890 J.L. Prescott & Co. Enameline set is a nine-piece series of die-cut paper dolls advertising Enameline stove polish, issued by J.L. Prescott & Co. of New York. Each doll shows a boy or girl in the colours of a college, playing a sport, and the set is catalogued as Z12-17 in Jefferson Burdick's American Card Catalog. The dolls were premiums: buy the polish, collect the set of "College Colors" dolls.
The complete set of nine is Bryn Mawr for tennis, Cornell for rowing, Harvard for cycling, Illinois Wesleyan for basketball, Oberlin for cricket, Princeton for baseball, Vassar for golf, Wellesley for croquet and Yale for football. The Illinois Wesleyan doll is one of the most talked-about pieces in the hobby, because it is often cited in the debate over the first basketball card, even though the card shows a boy holding a ball with no basket in sight and the back calls the pieces a set of nine dolls. A fold-out stand was attached to the back of each doll so it could stand on a table, which is why many collectors classify them as advertising trade cards or paper dolls rather than trading cards in the usual sense.
Vintage Card Company currently holds eight of the nine dolls in stock, all graded by SGC, missing only the Illinois Wesleyan basketball doll. The group includes the Harvard cycling, Cornell rowing, Oberlin cricket, Princeton baseball and Bryn Mawr tennis dolls, plus the Vassar golf, Wellesley croquet and Yale football dolls. Prices in this collection run from $360 to $720.
Frequently asked questions
Are the Enameline dolls trading cards? They are die-cut advertising trade cards, catalogued by Jefferson Burdick as paper dolls; the backs describe them as a set of nine dolls, and each originally had a fold-out stand.
How many dolls are in the complete set? Nine, one for each college and sport: Bryn Mawr, Cornell, Harvard, Illinois Wesleyan, Oberlin, Princeton, Vassar, Wellesley and Yale.
What was Enameline? A brand of stove polish made by J.L. Prescott & Co., which used the College Colors dolls as a sales premium in the 1890s.
