1908 E91-A Baseball
What is the 1908 E91-A Baseball? The 1908 E91-A Baseball collection covers the first of three annual caramel card series issued by the American Caramel Company. Known to collectors as E91-A, the 1908 set holds 33 cards featuring players from the Philadelphia Athletics, New York Giants, and Chicago Cubs. It was issued as a premium with American Caramel products, offering a candy alternative to the tobacco cards of the day, and it remains one of the most collectible pre-war caramel issues.
The E91 series is famous for a quirk that collectors still talk about: the same 33 generic illustrations were reused across all three years, with only the player's name and team changed. Jefferson Burdick, who cataloged the set in the American Card Catalog, called it the faked design set. The 1908 Set A is the strongest of the three, packed with Hall of Famers including Chief Bender, Roger Bresnahan, Mordecai Brown, Frank Chance, Johnny Evers, Christy Mathewson, John McGraw, Eddie Plank, and Joe Tinker. The backs read Base Ball Caramels at the top and carry a player checklist.
Both in-stock cards in this collection are Philadelphia Athletics players, each graded CSG 1. The Osee Schreckengost card, priced at $180, and the Daniel Murphy card, priced at $150, are classic low-grade pre-war survivors: more than a century old, genuinely scarce in any condition, and a direct link to the dead-ball era. Complete E91 sets are extremely rare, which makes even single cards from Set A a meaningful pickup for a pre-war collector.
Frequently asked questions
What is the E91-A set? The 1908 American Caramel series, 33 cards of Athletics, Giants, and Cubs players, the first of three annual E91 subsets issued from 1908 to 1910.
Why do E91 cards look alike? The American Caramel Company reused the same 33 generic illustrations across all three years, changing only the name and team, which is why Burdick called it the faked design set.
What cards are in this collection? An Osee Schreckengost card graded CSG 1 at $180 and a Daniel Murphy card graded CSG 1 at $150, both Philadelphia Athletics.
