1909 E91-B Baseball
What is the 1909 E91-B Baseball? The 1909 E91-B set is the middle issue of the American Caramel Company's three-year E91 series, a 33-card set of players from the Chicago Cubs, the Philadelphia Athletics and the New York Giants. The cards were issued as premiums with the company's caramel candy, an alternative for collectors too young to smoke, and they measure about 1-1/2 by 2-3/4 inches.
E91-B is part of a 99-card series: E91-A in 1908, E91-B in 1909 and E91-C in 1910, with 33 cards in each year. The three subsets look nearly identical, and the same 33 generic player illustrations were reused across them, with different players sharing the same pose. Jefferson Burdick, author of the American Card Catalog, called the design 'faked' for exactly that reason. The cards carry no numbers, and the backs read 'Base Ball Caramels' at the top above a player checklist, with 'Manufactured only by the American Caramel Co.' at the bottom.
Despite the generic artwork, the checklist is loaded. The 1909 set includes Hall of Famers Frank Baker, Chief Bender, Mordecai Brown, Frank Chance, Eddie Collins, Johnny Evers, Rube Marquard, Christy Mathewson, John McGraw, Ed Plank and Joe Tinker. The Cubs' famous infield is all here: Tinker, Evers and Chance. Complete sets are extremely rare, and even common cards in decent condition are scarce, because fewer E91 cards were printed in 1908 and production only grew as the card craze of 1909 took hold.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between E91-A, E91-B and E91-C? They are the three annual subsets of the American Caramel E91 series: E91-A in 1908, E91-B in 1909 and E91-C in 1910, with 33 cards each. E91-A and E91-B feature the Athletics, Giants and Cubs; E91-C switched to Pittsburgh, Washington and Boston players.
Why do E91 cards look generic? The same 33 illustrations were reused for two or three different players across the three subsets, so the artwork does not always match the player named. Burdick called it a 'faked design' in the American Card Catalog.
Who are the key cards in 1909 E91-B? Joe Tinker, Frank Chance and Christy Mathewson lead the set, with Frank Baker, Chief Bender, Mordecai Brown, Eddie Collins, Johnny Evers and Rube Marquard close behind.
