1916 Everybody's Baseball

What is the 1916 Everybody's Baseball? The 1916 Everybody's cards are M101-5 cards with the advertising back of Everybody's, the El Paso department store, printed on the reverse. They come from the 200-card M101-5 set produced by Chicago printer Felix Mendelsohn in 1916, a black-and-white issue measuring 1-5/8 by 3 inches that holds the card most collectors consider Babe Ruth's major league rookie card. Of the 18 businesses that advertised on M101-5 backs, Everybody's was long counted among the scarcest.

Mendelsohn sold his blank-backed cards in sets and sheets, and marketed them to businesses that stamped their own advertising on the backs and used them as premiums. Everybody's was a department store, and its back was considered one of the most difficult M101-5 backs to find until around 2008, when a find of about 60 Everybody's cards surfaced, roughly ten times the number previously known. Even after that find, the back remains scarce: most of the newly found cards covered only a small range of subjects, so team and player collectors still chase Everybody's backs hard. The full M101-5 checklist is loaded with Hall of Famers, from Ruth at number 151 through Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Walter Johnson, Tris Speaker, Shoeless Joe Jackson and Jim Thorpe.

Vintage Card Company currently holds five in-stock 1916 Everybody's cards, all graded by SGC. The group is led by a J.A. Niehoff graded SGC 5 at $1,000, followed by a Guy Morton graded SGC 6 at $600, a Fred Mollwitz graded SGC 5 at $500, a Steve O'Neill graded SGC 4.5 at $450, and a Rube Oldring graded SGC 4 at $375. Prices in this collection run from $375 to $1,000.

Frequently asked questions

What is an Everybody's card? A 1916 M101-5 card with the advertising back of Everybody's, an El Paso department store, printed on the reverse.

How many cards are in the M101-5 set? 200 cards, numbered in alphabetical order by the players' last names.

Why are Everybody's backs scarce? The back was long one of the hardest M101-5 advertising backs to find, and even after a find of about 60 cards around 2008, few different subjects are known with it.

Sort by:
1916 EVERYBODY'S J.A. NIEHOFF 132 EX SGC 5 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES

1916 EVERYBODY'S J.A. NIEHOFF 132 EX SGC 5 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES

$1,000.00
This J.A. NIEHOFF, from the 1916 EVERYBODY'S set, is in EX condition. This PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$1,000.00
1916 EVERYBODY'S GUY MORTON 128 EXMT SGC 6 BASEBALL CLEVELAND INDIANS

1916 EVERYBODY'S GUY MORTON 128 EXMT SGC 6 BASEBALL CLEVELAND INDIANS

$600.00
This GUY MORTON, from the 1916 EVERYBODY'S set, is in EXMT condition. This CLEVELAND INDIANS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$600.00
1916 EVERYBODY'S FRED MOLLWITZ 124 EX HIGHEST GRADED SGC 5 CINCINNATI REDS

1916 EVERYBODY'S FRED MOLLWITZ 124 EX HIGHEST GRADED SGC 5 CINCINNATI REDS

$500.00
This FRED MOLLWITZ, from the 1916 EVERYBODY'S set, is in EX condition. This CINCINNATI REDS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$500.00
1916 EVERYBODY'S STEVE O'NEILL 135 VG-EX+ SGC 4.5 BASEBALL CLEVELAND INDIANS

1916 EVERYBODY'S STEVE O'NEILL 135 VG-EX+ SGC 4.5 BASEBALL CLEVELAND INDIANS

$450.00
This STEVE O'NEILL, from the 1916 EVERYBODY'S set, is in VG-EX+ condition. This CLEVELAND INDIANS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$450.00
1916 EVERYBODY'S RUBE OLDRING 133 VG-EX SGC 4 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS

1916 EVERYBODY'S RUBE OLDRING 133 VG-EX SGC 4 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS

$375.00
This RUBE OLDRING, from the 1916 EVERYBODY'S set, is in VG-EX condition. This PHILADELPHIA ATHLETICS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$375.00