1917 Collins-McCarthy Baseball
What is the 1917 Collins-McCarthy Baseball? The 1917 Collins-McCarthy set, catalogued as E135, is a 200-card black-and-white issue from the Collins-McCarthy Candy Company of San Francisco — and one of the most historically curious sets in the hobby. The backs declare the 200 players to be Baseball's Hall of Fame, nearly 20 years before the actual Hall of Fame opened in Cooperstown in 1936. It was the company's only venture into major league players.
The cards measure 2 by 3-1/4 inches, with a player photograph, name, position, team and card number on the front. The same photographs were shared with the Boston Store, Standard Biscuit and Weil Baking issues of the same year, and blank-backed versions exist as well. The set is genuinely scarce: fewer than 2,000 examples in total have been graded by PSA and SGC combined, and the cards were printed on thin, glossy stock that is highly prone to creasing. The key cards are the greats of the era — Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner and Shoeless Joe Jackson — with Rogers Hornsby's card at number 80 his rookie card.
Vintage Card Company currently holds six in-stock 1917 Collins-McCarthy cards, all of them graded by SGC. The group is led by a Bill Killefer of the Philadelphia Phillies graded SGC 2.5 at $600, with a Fielder Jones of the St. Louis Browns graded SGC 5 and a Ferd Schupp of the New York Giants graded SGC 2, each at $360. Claude Hendrix of the Chicago Cubs and Ivan Howard of the Cleveland Indians, both graded SGC 3, are priced at $300 each, and a Dick Hoblitzell graded SGC 1 rounds out the group at $200.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the set call itself Baseball's Hall of Fame? The card backs state the 200 players make up Baseball's Hall of Fame — Collins-McCarthy's own hall, created about 20 years before the real Hall of Fame opened in Cooperstown in 1936.
How rare are 1917 Collins-McCarthy cards? Very rare. Fewer than 2,000 examples in total have been graded by PSA and SGC combined, and the thin, glossy stock creases easily, so high-grade copies are exceptionally scarce.
What is the key card in the set? Rogers Hornsby's card at number 80 is his rookie card and the most coveted single in the set, ahead of Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner and Shoeless Joe Jackson.
