1922 William Paterson Baseball
What is the 1922 William Paterson Baseball set? The William Paterson set, catalogued as V89 in Jefferson Burdick's American Card Catalog, is a 50-card issue from William Paterson Limited, a chocolatier and candy company based in Brantford, Ontario. Though it is a Canadian issue, it pictures American major league stars, and it is one of the rarest candy-card sets of the 1920s. The exact year of issue is not settled: the set is commonly dated 1922, though some sources place it in 1923 or 1924, and the store files it under 1922.
The checklist is remarkably strong for a 50-card candy issue. Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb headline the set, followed by Walter Johnson, Tris Speaker, Rogers Hornsby and Zack Wheat, among other stars of the era. Cards have been found in both black-and-white and sepia tones. Survival is extremely low: fewer than 70 V89 cards had been graded by PSA at the time Sports Collectors Daily profiled the set, and commons in decent shape generally start around $200, with Hall of Famers commanding far more. An SGC 30 Ty Cobb sold in 2015 for nearly $3,000, and the Ruth and Cobb cards are the set's great keys.
William Paterson also produced hockey sets in 1923-25, but the V89 baseball issue is the company's best-known card product, a small-town Canadian candy premium that somehow assembled the biggest names in the game. This collection currently holds one in-stock card from the set, including Frank Snyder, card 33, graded SGC 1. Snyder was the New York Giants' durable catcher of the 1920s, a member of John McGraw's pennant-winning clubs.
Frequently asked questions
How many cards are in the William Paterson set? Fifty cards, all American major league players.
Why is the set so rare? It was a small regional Canadian candy issue with very low survival, and fewer than 70 examples had been graded by PSA when the set was last profiled.
Who are the key cards? Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb headline the set, with Walter Johnson, Tris Speaker and Rogers Hornsby close behind.
