1923 Paulin's Candy Hockey

What is the 1923 Paulin's Candy hockey set? The 1923 Paulin's Candy set, catalogued as V128-1, is a 70-card hockey issue from Winnipeg chocolatier Paulin's, picturing players of the Western Canada Hockey League, an early rival of the NHL. The cards were found one per Paulin's Premium Hockey Bar, and a complete set of 70 could be sent to the company in exchange for a hockey stick or a box of chocolates. It was the first hockey card set produced after 1912, and it was aimed mostly at children.

The cards measure about 1-3/8 by 2-3/4 inches, printed on thin cardboard stock, with a black-and-white player photograph and the player's name on the front and a card number and the candy's redemption offer on the back. While many references call it a 1923-24 issue, there is evidence the cards were released through 1926. Cards that were redeemed were cancelled with a stamp or hole punch and returned to the owner, so uncancelled copies are prized. The key cards are George Hainsworth and Newsy LaLonde, with Red Dutton, Bill Cook and Joe Simpson also sought after, and the set includes rookie cards of several future Hall of Famers.

Only five complete sets appear on the PSA Population Report, all grading below Excellent, which says everything about how scarce this issue is in collectible condition. Vintage Card Company currently holds one in-stock card from this set, including a 1923 Paulin's Candy Ty Arbour, card 44, graded SGC 1.5, listed at $120. Arbour played for the Edmonton Eskimos of the Western Canada Hockey League.

Frequently asked questions

How many cards are in the 1923 Paulin's Candy set? 70 cards, picturing players of the Western Canada Hockey League.

How were the cards distributed? One per Paulin's Premium Hockey Bar, with a complete set redeemable for a hockey stick or a box of chocolates.

Who are the key cards? George Hainsworth and Newsy LaLonde lead the set, with Bill Cook and Red Dutton also popular.

Sort by:
1923 PAULIN'S CANDY TY ARBOUR 44 FAIR PAULIN CHAMBERS SGC 1.5 EDMONTON ESKIMOS

1923 PAULIN'S CANDY TY ARBOUR 44 FAIR PAULIN CHAMBERS SGC 1.5 EDMONTON ESKIMOS

$120.00
This TY ARBOUR, from the 1923 PAULIN'S CANDY set, is in FAIR condition. This EDMONTON ESKIMOS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in...
$120.00