1928 Harrington Ice Cream Baseball

What is the 1928 Harrington Ice Cream Baseball card set? The 1928 Harrington Ice Cream set is one of four issues in the F50 classification of Jefferson Burdick's American Card Catalog, the food-issue cards of 1928. Harrington's, an ice cream maker of Dushore, Pennsylvania, joined Yuengling's, Tharp's and the Sweetman candy company in issuing the same 60-card set of black-and-white baseball portraits, each measuring about one and three-eighths by two and a half inches, with only the advertising back differing between the four makers. The cards share their pictures with the 1927 York Caramels and the 1928 W502 strip card set.

The promotion on the back was the point of the set. Harrington's offered a gallon of ice cream for a complete 60-card set, and a Ruth card could be swapped for an ice cream novelty or saved toward quarts of ice cream. The checklist is loaded with Hall of Famers, more than a third of the issue, led by Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb, with Lou Gehrig, Rogers Hornsby, Tris Speaker, Grover Alexander, Pie Traynor and Paul Waner among the stars. Complete sets are virtually impossible to find, and Harrington's cards are significantly rarer than the Yuengling's issue, with only about 250 examples graded by PSA in total.

This collection holds two in-stock 1928 Harrington Ice Cream cards, including Herb Pennock, card number 8, graded SGC A for Authentic ($240), and Max Carey, card number 32, graded SGC 1 ($225). Pennock was the Hall of Fame left-hander of the Yankees' Murderers' Row teams, a six-time World Series champion, and his card is one of the set's star subjects from the 1928 season. Carey was the Hall of Fame outfielder who starred for Pittsburgh before finishing his career in Brooklyn, and his card is another of the set's star subjects.

Frequently asked questions

What is the F50 set? A 60-card black-and-white baseball issue of 1928, distributed by four food companies with the same fronts and different advertising backs.

What did Harrington's offer for a complete set? A gallon of ice cream for all 60 cards, with Ruth cards worth an ice cream novelty on their own.

Who are the key cards? Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb lead a checklist that is more than one-third Hall of Famers, including Lou Gehrig and Rogers Hornsby.

Sort by:
1928 HARRINGTON ICE CREAM HERB PENNOCK 8 VG F50 SGC A BASEBALL NEW YORK YANKEES

1928 HARRINGTON ICE CREAM HERB PENNOCK 8 VG F50 SGC A BASEBALL NEW YORK YANKEES

$240.00
This HERB PENNOCK, from the 1928 HARRINGTON ICE CREAM set, is in VG condition. This NEW YORK YANKEES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple...
$240.00
1928 HARRINGTON ICE CREAM MAX CAREY 32 F50 SGC 1 BASEBALL BROOKLYN DODGERS

1928 HARRINGTON ICE CREAM MAX CAREY 32 F50 SGC 1 BASEBALL BROOKLYN DODGERS

$225.00
This MAX CAREY, from the 1928.0 set, is in condition. This BROOKLYN DODGERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE payment. You...
$225.00