1928 Tharp's Ice Cream Baseball

What is the 1928 Tharp's Ice Cream Baseball set? The 1928 Tharp's Ice Cream set is a 60-card pre-war baseball issue from Tharp's Ice Cream of Shamokin, Pennsylvania, catalogued as F50 in Jefferson Burdick's American Card Catalog. The black-and-white cards measure about 1-3/8 by 2-1/2 inches and share their images with three sister issues from Yuengling, Harrington and Sweetman, differing only in the advertising printed on the back. A complete set could be redeemed for a gallon of Tharp's ice cream, a promotion that makes surviving examples a genuine piece of Depression-era Americana.

The checklist is loaded with the biggest names of the 1920s. Babe Ruth leads the set at card number 6, joined by Lou Gehrig, Ty Cobb, Rogers Hornsby, Tris Speaker, Pie Traynor and Grover Alexander. The four F50 distributors used the same photographs and nearly the same numbering, so the back is what separates a Tharp's card from its Yuengling or Harrington twin. Tharp's cards are the scarcest of the group after Sweetman, with only about 150 Tharp's examples graded by PSA, and even low-grade commons typically sell in the hundred-dollar range. Vintage Card Company currently holds one card from this set in stock, including the John McInnis card number 60, graded Poor by SGC at 1.

Because the cards were a regional ice cream promotion, most were handled by children and redeemed, damaged or thrown away, so high-grade survivors are rare and the set is considered complete at 59 or 60 cards depending on how collectors treat the elusive Earl Smith card. For pre-war collectors, a Tharp's back is one of the toughest F50 variations to find.

Frequently asked questions

How many cards are in the 1928 Tharp's Ice Cream set? The set has 60 cards, numbered 1 through 60, though some collectors consider it complete at 59 because the Earl Smith card is so rarely seen with a Tharp's back.

What does F50 mean? F50 is Jefferson Burdick's American Card Catalog designation for this group of food-issued sets, with the F standing for food, covering the Tharp's, Yuengling, Harrington and Sweetman issues of 1928.

Why are Tharp's cards scarcer than other F50 cards? Tharp's was a small regional ice cream maker in Shamokin, Pennsylvania, so far fewer cards were distributed than the Yuengling and Harrington issues, and many were redeemed for ice cream and never returned to collectors.

Sort by:
1928 THARP'S ICE CREAM JOHN MCINNIS 60 POOR SGC 1 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES

1928 THARP'S ICE CREAM JOHN MCINNIS 60 POOR SGC 1 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES

$360.00
This JOHN MCINNIS, from the 1928 THARP'S ICE CREAM set, is in POOR condition. This PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards...
$360.00