1996 Select Football

What is the 1996 Select Football collection? 1996 Select Football is Pinnacle Brands' Select issue for the 1996 NFL season, and this collection holds three copies of its most famous card: John Elway's #8 Prime Cut insert. Elway, the Denver Broncos quarterback and eventual two-time Super Bowl champion, is the centerpiece of any 1996 Select football collection, and the Prime Cut cards here are his insert from the set — two graded MCG 10 and one graded MCG 9, all priced at $11.

Select was Pinnacle's mid-1990s brand, known for its distinctive horizontal card designs and for parallels like Artist's Proofs. The football issue's base checklist includes Elway at #40, per the PSA Set Registry, and the Prime Cut insert is one of the set's chase inserts — a die-cut style card highlighting the game's stars. Elway was in the back half of his career in 1996, two seasons from his first Super Bowl title, and his cards from this era remain popular with Broncos collectors and Hall of Fame collectors alike.

The three cards in this collection are identical in subject but distinct in grade: two gem-mint MCG 10 copies and one mint MCG 9, all of the same Elway #8 Prime Cut card. For a player collector, that makes this a small study in condition — the same card, three grades, one price.

Frequently asked questions

What is Prime Cut? A 1996 Select football insert set featuring the game's stars, including John Elway at #8.

What is John Elway's base card in 1996 Select? Elway is #40 in the 1996 Select football base set, per the PSA Set Registry.

Why are there three copies of the same card here? The store holds three copies of the Elway #8 Prime Cut card in different grades — two MCG 10 and one MCG 9 — and all three are listed separately, as the store lists duplicate titles individually.

Sort by:
p-152980 image position 1

1996 SELECT JOHN ELWAY 8 GEM MINT MCG 10 PRIME CUT 35065 FOOTBALL DENVER BRONCOS

$11.00
A JOHN ELWAY from the 1996 SELECT set, card #8. This is a great addition to any DENVER BRONCOS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 10 This card is in Gem...
$11.00
p-152979 image position 1

1996 SELECT JOHN ELWAY 8 MINT MCG 9 PRIME CUT 35065 FOOTBALL DENVER BRONCOS

$11.00
A JOHN ELWAY from the 1996 SELECT set, card #8. This is a great addition to any DENVER BRONCOS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 9 This card is in fantastic...
$11.00
p-152978 image position 1

1996 SELECT JOHN ELWAY 8 GEM MINT MCG 10 PRIME CUT 35065 FOOTBALL DENVER BRONCOS

$11.00
A JOHN ELWAY from the 1996 SELECT set, card #8. This is a great addition to any DENVER BRONCOS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 10 This card exhibits nearly flawless...
$11.00