Old Judge Baseball

What is the Old Judge Baseball collection? This collection holds five in-stock cards from the Old Judge issue, catalogued as N172, the first great baseball card set and one of the most important issues in the hobby. Goodwin and Company of New York issued the cards from 1887 to 1890 to promote its Old Judge and Gypsy Queen cigarettes, placing sepia-toned albumen photographs from the Hall Studio in New York onto thick cardboard, with blank backs. The cards measure about one and a half by two and a half inches, and they depict more than 500 players from the National League, the American Association, the Players League and the minor leagues of the day, along with boxers and wrestlers.

There is no single Old Judge set in the usual sense. More than 4,500 different card types and variations are known, with some 2,491 player-and-pose combinations catalogued in the definitive study of the issue, because the same player often appears in several poses, in uniform and in street clothes. Stars and Hall of Famers in the issue include Cap Anson, Dan Brouthers, Roger Connor, Buck Ewing, Pud Galvin, Kid Nichols, Jim O'Rourke, Old Hoss Radbourne and Amos Rusie.

The five cards in this collection are all dated 1887 in the store and all professionally graded. The leader is a Tom Loftus of the Cleveland Spiders, graded SGC 2, followed by a John Crooks of Omaha, graded PSA 3.5, and a Henry Gruber of the Cleveland Spiders, graded SGC 1.5. A Charles Buffington of the Philadelphia Quakers, graded SGC 1.5, and a Parson Nicholson of the St. Louis Whites, graded SGC 1, complete a group of genuine nineteenth-century photographic cards, each nearly 140 years old.

Frequently asked questions

How many cards are in the Old Judge set? The issue covers more than 500 players with over 2,491 known player-and-pose combinations, and more than 4,500 card types and variations when all poses, teams and brands are counted.

Who issued Old Judge cards? Goodwin and Company of New York, maker of Old Judge and Gypsy Queen cigarettes. The cards were inserted in cigarette packs from 1887 to 1890.

Why are Old Judge cards so prized? They are true photographic cards from the first nationally distributed baseball set, picturing the stars of the 1880s in an era when very few images of ballplayers existed at all.

Sort by:
1887 OLD JUDGE TOM LOFTUS 277-1a GOOD N172 SGC 2 BASEBALL CLEVELAND SPIDERS

1887 OLD JUDGE TOM LOFTUS 277-1a GOOD N172 SGC 2 BASEBALL CLEVELAND SPIDERS

$1,500.00
This TOM LOFTUS, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in GOOD condition.This CLEVELAND SPIDERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$1,500.00
1887 OLD JUDGE JOHN CROOKS NNO VG N172 PSA 3.5 BASEBALL OMAHA OMAHOGS

1887 OLD JUDGE JOHN CROOKS NNO VG N172 PSA 3.5 BASEBALL OMAHA OMAHOGS

$1,100.00
This JOHN CROOKS, from the 1887 set, is in condition.This OMAHA OMAHOGS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE payment. You will...
$1,100.00
1887 OLD JUDGE HENRY GRUBER 202-3 FAIR N172 SGC 1.5 BASEBALL CLEVELAND SPIDERS

1887 OLD JUDGE HENRY GRUBER 202-3 FAIR N172 SGC 1.5 BASEBALL CLEVELAND SPIDERS

$750.00
This HENRY GRUBER, from the 1887 OLD JUDGE set, is in FAIR condition.This CLEVELAND SPIDERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE...
$750.00
1887 OLD JUDGE PARSON NICHOLSON NNO POOR N172 SGC 1 BASEBALL ST. LOUIS WHITES

1887 OLD JUDGE PARSON NICHOLSON NNO POOR N172 SGC 1 BASEBALL ST. LOUIS WHITES

$500.00
This PARSON NICHOLSON, from the 1887 set, is in condition.This ST. LOUIS WHITES card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE payment. You...
$500.00
1887 OLD JUDGE CHARLES BUFFINGTON NNO FAIR N172 SGC 1.5 PHILADELPHIA QUAKERS

1887 OLD JUDGE CHARLES BUFFINGTON NNO FAIR N172 SGC 1.5 PHILADELPHIA QUAKERS

$500.00
This CHARLES BUFFINGTON, from the 1887 set, is in condition.This PHILADELPHIA QUAKERS card is a great addition to any collection. Please pay for multiple cards in ONE payment. You will...
$500.00