1940 Play Ball Baseball

What is the 1940 Play Ball baseball card set? The 1940 Play Ball set is Gum, Inc.’s second and largest baseball issue, and one of the most underrated pre-war sets in the hobby. The Philadelphia company issued 240 cards in penny packs with gum, matching 1933 Goudey as the largest single-year gum set to that point. Each card measures 2-1/2 by 3-1/8 inches and carries a black-and-white photograph by former White Sox and Cubs photographer George Burke, framed by a more elaborate border than the 1939 issue. The set is catalogued as R335 in the American Card Catalog.

The checklist mixes the stars of 1940 with the legends of the past. Joe DiMaggio leads the set at card #1 — a major condition rarity, since the top card in a stack takes the most wear, with only two PSA 9s and eight PSA 8s in existence. Ted Williams appears at #27 in his second year, and the set’s most unusual card is “Shoeless” Joe Jackson at #225, issued decades after his banishment from baseball and one of his very few appearances in a prominent card set. Retired greats including Honus Wagner, Christy Mathewson, Walter Johnson and Tris Speaker fill out the high numbers, cards 181 through 240, which are noticeably scarcer than the low series. Jimmie Foxx, Hank Greenberg, Mel Ott and Bob Feller are among the other keys.

High-grade 1940 Play Ball cards are genuinely tough: the set is known for condition problems that the 1939 and 1941 issues do not share to the same degree. The card design later found a second life in the movies — the 1940 Play Ball look was recreated for the cards in The Natural.

Frequently asked questions

Who are the key cards in 1940 Play Ball? Joe DiMaggio #1, Ted Williams #27 and Shoeless Joe Jackson #225 are the big three, followed by Foxx, Greenberg and Ott.

Why is the set black and white? Gum, Inc. used George Burke’s black-and-white photography for all three Play Ball issues, 1939 to 1941.

How many cards are in the 1940 Play Ball set? 240 cards, issued in two series: #1-144 and #145-240.

Sort by:
p-161730 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL BILLY JURGES 89 VG MCG 3 BASEBALL NEW YORK GIANTS

$14.00
A BILLY JURGES from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #89. This is a great addition to any NEW YORK GIANTS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 3 This vintage 1940...
$14.00
p-104457 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL DEL YOUNG 101 GOOD MCG 2 BASEBALL PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES

$14.00
A DEL YOUNG from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #101. This is a great addition to any PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 2 This card is in...
$14.00
p-104240 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL PETE COSCARART 63 VG MCG 3 BASEBALL BROOKLYN DODGERS

$14.00
A PETE COSCARART from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #63. This is a great addition to any BROOKLYN DODGERS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 3 The grade is primarily...
$14.00
p-15855 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL CHARLEY GELBERT 18 VG MCG 3 BASEBALL WASHINGTON SENATORS

$12.00
A CHARLEY GELBERT from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #18. This is a great addition to any WASHINGTON SENATORS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 3 This vintage 1940 card...
$12.00
p-161992 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL CHUCK DRESSEN 72 POOR MCG 1 RC BASEBALL BROOKLYN DODGERS

$12.00
A CHUCK DRESSEN from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #72. This is a great addition to any BROOKLYN DODGERS collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 1 Despite boasting exceptional centering...
$12.00
p-161925 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL JOHNNY RIZZO 108 GOOD MCG 2 BASEBALL PITTSBURGH PIRATES

$12.00
A JOHNNY RIZZO from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #108. This is a great addition to any PITTSBURGH PIRATES collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 2 This card is in...
$12.00
p-161608 image position 1

1940 PLAY BALL JOE HEVING 35 GOOD MCG 2 BASEBALL BOSTON RED SOX

$12.00
A JOE HEVING from the 1940 PLAY BALL set, card #35. This is a great addition to any BOSTON RED SOX collection. Graded by Mint Condition: 2 This card's grade...
$12.00